120 Homes for Sale in Montauk, New York

Name: Quiet Montauk Opportunity
Brand: Saunders & Associates
Price: 1995000 USD
Availability: inStock

Gallery

Hybrid

Map

selected listings

select all

remove all

Single Family Home for Sale at Quiet Montauk Opportunity 123 Fairview Avenue, Montauk, NY 11954

Ed Gaetjens

Licensed Real Estate Salesperson as Edmund Christopher Gaetjens

201-707-7178

eg@saunders.com

Saunders & Associates

Contract

Montauk

Quiet Montauk Opportunity

123 Fairview Avenue, Montauk, NY 11954

3bd2ba1,845SF

: Single Family Home

$1,995,000

$1,081/SF

Reduced:5/21/2025$2,250,000(-1.96%)

Date	Price	Variance	Type
5/21/2025	$2,250,000	-1.96%	Reduced
3/12/2025	$2,295,000	+15.04%	increased
2/12/2025	$1,995,000	-	Listed

Single Family Home for Sale at Montauk Waterfront - Half-Acre High Above Fort Pond Bay 96 Tuthill Road, Montauk, NY 11954

Pete Moore Jr

Licensed Real Estate Salesperson

631-807-4635

pete.moore@corcoran.com

Corcoran Group (East Hampton)

Montauk

Montauk Waterfront - Half-Acre High Above Fort Pond Bay

96 Tuthill Road, Montauk, NY 11954

2bd1ba1,255SF

: Single Family Home

$1,995,000

$1,590/SF

increased:3/29/2025$2,250,000(+12.78%)

Date	Price	Variance	Type
3/29/2025	$2,250,000	+12.78%	increased
2/10/2025	$1,995,000	-	Listed

Land for Sale at Montauk Waterfront - Half-Acre High Above Fort Pond Bay 96 Tuthill Road, Montauk, NY 11954

Pete Moore Jr

Licensed Real Estate Salesperson

631-807-4635

pete.moore@corcoran.com

Corcoran Group (East Hampton)

Montauk

Montauk Waterfront - Half-Acre High Above Fort Pond Bay

96 Tuthill Road, Montauk, NY 11954

: Land

$1,995,000

increased:3/29/2025$2,250,000(+12.78%)

Date	Price	Variance	Type
3/29/2025	$2,250,000	+12.78%	increased
2/10/2025	$1,995,000	-	Listed

Single Family Home for Sale at Hither Hills Beach Access 56 Edison Drive, Montauk, NY 11954

Dawn Neway

Licensed Sales Associate

203-809-4688

DawnandDiana.Neway@elliman.com

Douglas Elliman (East Hampton)

Montauk

Hither Hills Beach Access

56 Edison Drive, Montauk, NY 11954

4bd3ba2,400SF

: Single Family Home

$2,495,000

$1,040/SF

Listed:2/2/2025$2,495,000

Single Family Home for Sale at Stunning Montauk Lakefront 24 Lakeside Court, Montauk, NY 11954

Sam Crumm

Licensed Salesperson

631-668-3500

914-844-1429

sam.crumm@corcoran.com

Corcoran Group (Montauk)

Contract

Montauk

Stunning Montauk Lakefront

24 Lakeside Court, Montauk, NY 11954

4bd3ba3,572SF

: Single Family Home

$5,995,000

$1,678/SF

Reduced:3/30/2025$6,500,000(-7.08%)

Date	Price	Variance	Type
3/30/2025	$6,500,000	-7.08%	Reduced
2/25/2025	$6,995,000	+16.68%	increased
1/31/2025	$5,995,000	-	Listed

Co-op Properties for Sale at Montauk, NY 11954

Mary Ann Peluso

Licensed Real Estate Salesperson

917-992-2251

MaryAnn.Peluso@corcoran.com

Corcoran Group (Montauk)

Montauk

402 West Lake Drive, 14

Montauk, NY 11954

2bd1ba800SF

: Co-op Properties

$1,475,000

$1,844/SF

Listed:1/25/2025$1,475,000

Single Family Home for Sale at 16 Stuyvesant Drive, Montauk / Hither Hill's Beach Rights Montauk, NY 11954

David J Ryan

Real Estate Salesperson

516-702-0816

dave.ryan@raveis.com

William Raveis (Montauk)

Montauk

16 Stuyvesant Drive, Montauk / Hither Hill's Beach Rights

Montauk, NY 11954

3bd2ba1,474SF

: Single Family Home

$1,795,000

$1,218/SF

Reduced:4/25/2025$1,850,000(-1.33%)

Date	Price	Variance	Type
4/25/2025	$1,850,000	-1.33%	Reduced
2/26/2025	$1,875,000	-2.60%	Reduced
1/23/2025	$1,925,000	+7.24%	increased
1/19/2025	$1,795,000	-	Listed

Commercial for Sale at Mixed Use Investment Property Offering Three Floors 45 South Euclid Avenue, Montauk, NY 11954

Hal Zwick

631-678-2460

hal.zwick@compass.com

Compass

Montauk

Mixed Use Investment Property Offering Three Floors

45 South Euclid Avenue, Montauk, NY 11954

2bd2ba2,910SF

: Commercial

$2,650,000

$911/SF

Listed:12/31/2024$2,650,000

Single Family Home for Sale at Oceanfront Compound Opportunity On The Break 40 & 42 Deforest Road, Montauk, NY 11954

Hedgerow Exclusive Team

631-296-8543

listings@hedgerowexclusive.com

Hedgerow Exclusive Properties

Montauk

Oceanfront Compound Opportunity On The Break

40 & 42 Deforest Road, Montauk, NY 11954

14bd12ba

: Single Family Home

$37,500,000

increased:12/31/2024$39,995,000(+6.65%)

Date	Price	Variance	Type
12/31/2024	$39,995,000	+6.65%	increased
12/29/2024	$37,500,000	-	Listed

Erica Grossman

Licensed Sales Associate

917-710-2512

Erica.Grossman@elliman.com

Douglas Elliman (Southampton)

Montauk

Oceanfront Compound Opportunity On The Break

40 & 42 Deforest Road, Montauk, NY 11954

14bd12ba

: Single Family Home

$37,500,000

increased:12/31/2024$39,995,000(+6.65%)

Date	Price	Variance	Type
12/31/2024	$39,995,000	+6.65%	increased
12/29/2024	$37,500,000	-	Listed

Single Family Home for Sale at Move-In Ready In Ditch Plains With Four Bedrooms 12 Flagg Avenue, Montauk, NY 11954

Chris Coleman

Licensed Real Estate Salesperson

631-668-2000

516-445-1513

chris.coleman@compass.com

Compass

Contract

Montauk

Move-In Ready In Ditch Plains With Four Bedrooms

12 Flagg Avenue, Montauk, NY 11954

4bd2ba1,400SF

: Single Family Home

$2,390,000

$1,707/SF

increased:12/14/2024$2,495,000(+4.39%)

Date	Price	Variance	Type
12/14/2024	$2,495,000	+4.39%	increased
12/9/2024	$2,390,000	-	Listed

Single Family Home for Sale at Montauk Opportunity With Ocean Views - Your Dream Canvas Awaits 26 Birch Drive, Montauk, NY 11954

Compass

Montauk Opportunity With Ocean Views - Your Dream Canvas Awaits

26 Birch Drive, Montauk, NY 11954

3bd2ba3,564SF

: Single Family Home

$2,550,000

$715/SF

increased:12/14/2024$2,700,000(+5.88%)

Date	Price	Variance	Type
12/14/2024	$2,700,000	+5.88%	increased
11/30/2024	$2,550,000	-	Listed

1 2 3 4 567 8 9 10

Cities near Montauk

Montauk Homes For Sale

zip codes near Montauk

Google Map Loading...

a1146f067-9ef1-45b2-a533-0d543ba92855

units of measure

Currency

Language

120 Homes for Sale in Montauk, New York

Cities near Montauk

Montauk Homes For Sale

zip codes near Montauk