Skip to main content
My Portfolio
Log in
.
Sign Up
global settings
units of measure
Activating this element will cause content on the page to be updated
Metric
U.S.
Currency
American Dollar (USD)
Argentine Peso (ARS)
Aruban Florin (AWG)
Australian Dollar (AUD)
Bahamas Dollars (BSD)
Bahrain Dinars (BHD)
Barbados Dollars (BBD)
Belize Dollars (BZD)
Bermuda Dollars (BMD)
Bitcoin (BTC)
Brazilian Real (BRL)
British Pound (GBP)
Brunei dollar (BND)
Cambodia Riels (KHR)
Canadian Dollar (CAD)
Cayman Islands Dollars (KYD)
Chilean Peso (CLP)
Chilean Unit of Account (UF) (CLF)
Chinese Yuan (CNY)
Colombian Peso (COP)
Costa Rica Colones (CRC)
hrk (HRK)
Czech Republic Koruny (CZK)
Dominican Republic Pesos (DOP)
East Caribbean Dollars (XCD)
Egypt Pounds (EGP)
Euro (EUR)
Hong Kong Dollar (HKD)
Indian Rupee (INR)
Indonesia Rupiahs (IDR)
Israeli New Shekel (ILS)
jmd (JMD)
Japanese Yen (JPY)
Kazakhstan Tenge (KZT)
Kuwaiti Dinar (KWD)
Malaysian Ringgit (MYR)
Mauritius Rupee (MUR)
Mexican Peso (MXN)
Morocco Dirhams (MAD)
New Zealand Dollar (NZD)
Oman Rials (OMR)
Pacific Franc (XPF)
Philippines Pesos (PHP)
Poland Zlotych (PLN)
Qatari Rial (QAR)
Romanian Leu (RON)
Russian Ruble (RUB)
Saudi Arabia Riyals (SAR)
Singapore Dollar (SGD)
South African Rand (ZAR)
South Korean Won (KRW)
lkr (LKR)
Swedish Krona (SEK)
Swiss Franc (CHF)
Taiwan Dollar (TWD)
Thai Baht (THB)
Trinidad and Tobago Dollar (TTD)
Turkish Lira (TRY)
United Arab Emirates Dirhams (AED)
Venezuelan Bolivar (VEF)
Vietnam Dong (VND)
Language
English - United States
Español - América
Español - Europa
Deutsch
Français - Canada
Français - Europe
Italiano
日本語
Português - Brasil
Português - Europeu
Русский
中文 -简体
中文 -繁體
Tiếng Việt Nam
한국어
Türkçe
Nederlands
Svenska
ελληνικά
Sales
Hamptons
All Listings
Open Houses
Price Reduced
New Listings
Recently Sold
North Fork
All Listings
Open Houses
Price Reduced
New Listings
Recently Sold
Rentals
Hamptons
All Listings
Open Houses
New Listings
North Fork
All Listings
Open Houses
New Listings
Open Houses
Hamptons
For Sale
Today
Tomorrow
Next 7 Days
Upcoming Weekend
For Rent
Today
Tomorrow
Next 7 Days
Upcoming Weekend
North Fork
Today
Tomorrow
Next 7 Days
Upcoming Weekend
Sold
Hamptons
North Fork
BROKERAGES
Agents
About Us
More
Menu
Location
Map
Draw Area
Radius
Status
(0)
active
Open Houses
All
Today
Tomorrow
Next 7 Days
Upcoming Weekend
Virtual
On-site
New Listings
Past 7 Days
Today
Past 30 Days
Past 60 Days
Past 90 Days
price reduced
Within 60 Days
All
Today
Within 1 Month
Within 6 months
In Contract
All
Today
Price
(0)
Currency :
USD
Bedrooms
(0)
Bedrooms
1+
2+
3+
4+
5+
Bathrooms
(0)
Bathrooms
1+
2+
3+
4+
5+
Type
(0)
Commercial
Condominium
Co-Op
Land
Single Family
Townhouse
Square Feet
(0)
Amenities
(0)
Artist Studio
Barn
Bayfront
Dock
Elevator
Finished Lower Level
Garage
Guest House
Gym
Main Level Master Suite
Media Room / Home Theater
New Construction
Oceanfront
Pets Allowed
Pool
Pool House
Room for Pool
Room for Tennis
South of The Highway
Spa
Tennis
Waterfront
Waterview
Acres
(0)
Virtual
(0)
Virtual Tour 3D
Videos
Other
(0)
Keyword
(0)
Show Less Filters
More
0
Advanced Search
Cancel
search
74 Homes for Sale
in Shelter Island Heights, New York
Gallery
Hybrid
Map
Filter: By State
Sort by New Listings
Sort by Price High-Low
Sort by Price Low-High
Sort by Bedrooms
Sort by Square Feet
selected listings
select all
remove all
E-mail
Print
Compare
Route Planner
Save
images
video
contact
map
1
of 40
TinaMarika Kaasik
Real Estate Salesperson
631-749-1155
401-862-6607
tinamarikakaasik@danielgale.com
Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty
Shelter Island Heights
Historic Shelter Island Heights Home With Pool And Cottage.
Historic Shelter Island Heights Home With Pool And Cottage.
31 Grand Ave+ 20 Spring Garden Ave
,
Shelter Island Heights
,
NY
11965
6
bd
4
ba
2,640
SF
Single Family Home
$3,200,000
$1,212
/SF
Listed:
3/19/2025
$3,200,000
images
video
contact
map
1
of 34
Theresa Andrew
Licensed Real Estate Salesperson
631-749-3093
631-258-4707
tandrew@corcoran.com
Corcoran Group (Shelter Island)
Shelter Island Heights
First Time Listed... A Place To Call Home
First Time Listed... A Place To Call Home
9 Worthy Way
,
Shelter Island Heights
,
NY
11964
3
bd
2
ba
2,060
SF
Single Family Home
$1,350,000
$655
/SF
Listed:
3/10/2025
$1,350,000
images
contact
map
1
of 2
Penelope A Moore
Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker
631-749-5801
917-208-5519
PMoore@Saunders.com
Saunders & Associates
Shelter Island Heights
Shelter Island Pristine Ram Island Acreage
Shelter Island Pristine Ram Island Acreage
1 Tuthill Drive
,
Shelter Island Heights
,
NY
11964
Land
$925,000
Listed:
2/25/2025
$925,000
images
video
contact
map
1
of 36
Penelope A Moore
Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker
631-749-5801
917-208-5519
PMoore@Saunders.com
Saunders & Associates
Shelter Island Heights
1887 Dering Harbor Village Victorian With Pool And Dock
1887 Dering Harbor Village Victorian With Pool And Dock
8 Gardiner Way And 15a Harbor Lane
,
Shelter Island Heights
,
NY
11964
5
bd
3
ba
4,053
SF
Single Family Home
$6,750,000
$1,665
/SF
Listed:
2/24/2025
$6,750,000
images
video
contact
map
1
of 24
Penelope A Moore
Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker
631-749-5801
917-208-5519
PMoore@Saunders.com
Saunders & Associates
Shelter Island Heights
Shelter Island Modernist Gem With Pool And Guest House
Shelter Island Modernist Gem With Pool And Guest House
24 Rocky Point Road
,
Shelter Island Heights
,
NY
11964
4
bd
2
ba
2,890
SF
Single Family Home
$3,600,000
$1,246
/SF
Listed:
2/13/2025
$3,600,000
images
video
contact
map
1
of 32
Penelope A Moore
Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker
631-749-5801
917-208-5519
PMoore@Saunders.com
Saunders & Associates
Shelter Island Heights
Shelter Island Cape Cod With Pool Near Beach
Shelter Island Cape Cod With Pool Near Beach
30 Brander Parkway
,
Shelter Island Heights
,
NY
11964
3
bd
3
ba
1,933
SF
Single Family Home
$1,675,000
$867
/SF
increased:
2/13/2025
$1,795,000
(+7.16%)
Date
Price
Variance
Type
2/13/2025
$1,795,000
+7.16%
increased
2/11/2025
$1,675,000
-
Listed
images
video
contact
map
1
of 14
Jeremy Dunham
Associate Real Estate Broker
631-875-2475
jeremydunham@compass.com
Compass
Shelter Island Heights
Masterful New Construction
Masterful New Construction
11 Sunnyside Avenue
,
Shelter Island Heights
,
NY
11965
4
bd
4
ba
4,000
SF
Single Family Home
$5,500,000
$1,375
/SF
Listed:
1/15/2025
$5,500,000
images
contact
map
1
of 18
Breitenbach Advisory Team
Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker
631-268-4404
bat@compass.com
Compass
Shelter Island Heights
The Ultimate Waterfront Compound
The Ultimate Waterfront Compound
3a/3b Pandion Rd, 3a/3b
,
Shelter Island Heights
,
NY
11964
Land
$6,999,000
Listed:
1/13/2025
$6,999,000
images
video
contact
map
1
of 39
Penelope A Moore
Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker
631-749-5801
917-208-5519
PMoore@Saunders.com
Saunders & Associates
Shelter Island Heights
Shelter Island Turn-Key Country Cape
Shelter Island Turn-Key Country Cape
20 Bowditch Road
,
Shelter Island Heights
,
NY
11964
4
bd
2
ba
1,831
SF
Single Family Home
$1,195,000
$653
/SF
Listed:
12/7/2024
$1,195,000
images
video
contact
map
1
of 9
Theresa Andrew
Licensed Real Estate Salesperson
631-749-3093
631-258-4707
tandrew@corcoran.com
Corcoran Group (Shelter Island)
Shelter Island Heights
Not To Be Missed...
Not To Be Missed...
13 Winthrop Road, Unit# 30
,
Shelter Island Heights
,
NY
11965
1
bd
1
ba
650
SF
Co-op Properties
$565,000
$869
/SF
increased:
12/20/2024
$595,000
(+5.31%)
Date
Price
Variance
Type
12/20/2024
$595,000
+5.31%
increased
11/20/2024
$565,000
-
Listed
images
video
contact
map
1
of 25
Adam Hofer
Licensed Real Estate Salesperson
631-236-8659
Adam.Hofer@elliman.com
Douglas Elliman (Southampton)
Shelter Island Heights
Serious Seller Wants You In For Summer!
Serious Seller Wants You In For Summer!
10 B Sunshine Road
,
Shelter Island Heights
,
NY
11964
4
bd
4
ba
5,300
SF
Single Family Home
$2,795,000
$527
/SF
Listed:
11/14/2024
$2,795,000
images
video
contact
map
1
of 35
Rebecca M Shafer
Licensed Real Estate Salesperson
917-545-6767
Rebecca.Shafer@corcoran.com
Corcoran Group (Shelter Island)
Shelter Island Heights
Fox Hollow Farm
Fox Hollow Farm
79 North Midway Road
,
Shelter Island Heights
,
NY
11964
8
bd
6
ba
8,000
SF
Single Family Home
$7,425,000
$928
/SF
increased:
1/15/2025
$8,750,000
(+17.85%)
Date
Price
Variance
Type
1/15/2025
$8,750,000
+17.85%
increased
11/10/2024
$7,425,000
-
Listed
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
United States
New York
Shelter Island Heights
Google Map Loading...
a7b3781b8-516d-445e-b367-9cfc6fd9e54d
